The holiday season can test even the most cooperative co-parenting relationships. Families that once shared traditions now have two households, two sets of plans and often two extended families hoping to spend time with the children. Without a clear holiday custody schedule, that uncertainty can turn a usually magical time of year into a stressful one. A well-drafted custody order can resolve most holiday conflicts before they start.
Families take many forms today. Children may be raised by two moms or two dads, by parents who never married, by adoptive or nonbiological parents or by blended families that include stepparents and stepsiblings. Grandparents and other extended relations may also play a central role in a child’s family. Whatever your family might look like during the holiday season, the same main principle is to put children first in your holiday planning.
Where to Start
As you develop a holiday schedule, begin with the traditions that have become important to your family. For example, some families enjoy a Christmas Eve “Feast of the Seven Fishes” including extended family from around the world. Others may put emphasis on Christmas morning and opening presents. Still others may traditionally celebrate with extended family on certain nights of the Hanukkah holiday. When possible, it may make sense to carry over some family traditions. When that is not possible, it can be an opportunity for each home to create new traditions.
In any event, it is important to consider the practical details when working on holiday custody schedules:
Work Schedules
If one parent typically works on a particular holiday, it often makes sense for the other parent to have the children that day.
Travel
Plans to visit out-of-town relatives, or accommodate the schedules of visiting relatives, should be raised early so both households can plan around them.
The School Calendar
Review winter break dates along with any performances, practices, games or other events already on the children’s calendars.
Extended Family
Consider which gatherings matter most on each side of the family, including stepfamilies and relatives who have been a consistent presence in the children’s lives.
Creating Periods of Rest
It is important to remember that the winter break holidays are a time when the children need their extended time off from school to rest and regroup. It is important to avoid excessive transitions, early wake ups and overscheduling when possible.
Above all, keep your children’s best interests at the center of every decision.
Common Approaches to Holiday Schedules
Many families alternate major winter holidays such as Thanksgiving, Hanukkah, Kwanzaa, Christmas Eve, Christmas Day and New Year’s Eve from year to year. For example, one parent may have Thanksgiving in even-numbered years while the other parent has it in odd-numbered years. The parent who does not have Thanksgiving often has Christmas Eve overnight, with a transition on Christmas Day, so the children share the holiday with both parents. Families who celebrate Hanukkah, Kwanzaa or other holidays should account for the days that matter most to them. Because those holidays are celebrated over multiple days, it may be possible to give both parents time during those holidays.
However, alternating holidays may not make sense for every family. When both households live close to one another and do not typically travel during the holidays, parents may be able to split each holiday so the children spend part of every special day with both.
Another option is to split the children’s winter break equally. This approach often works well for parents who live farther apart or who want time to travel with their children or who believe their children will benefit from not being required to engage in frequent transitions. s
Additionally, while some holidays are only celebrated on a single day (like Thanksgiving), there may be adjoining days off that can either be shared with the parent who did not enjoy the actual holiday, or be used to allow the parent with the holiday a more extended opportunity to travel or visit non-local extended family.
In some cases, co-parents get along well enough to spend parts of the holidays together with their children. This is not typical and can be difficult to sustain over time, as new partners, moves and changing schedules alter family dynamics. Families who choose this route should still have a written schedule to fall back on.
Decide on the Details
Another issue to keep in mind during the holiday season is that of snow days and sick days which are more prevalent during the winter. There should be a plan in place to address who will be responsible for the children when school is canceled or delayed due to inclement weather or when the children cannot attend school due to illness. Often the parent who has custody that day cares for the children or arranges other appropriate childcare. There should be a time for transitions to occur when they cannot occur at pick up from school or the bus stop or childcare to prevent confusion as to when a parent’s custodial time begins on a non-school day.
Whatever your holiday custody schedule, it’s very important to be specific about dates and times. The right holiday custody schedule should be customized to your family’s needs. It should also address transportation and how co-parents will communicate about any proposed changes. Clear terms leave less room for misunderstanding when emotions run high.
Stay Flexible Yet Focused
Regardless of the schedule in place, do your best to keep the holiday spirit by being flexible with your co-parent when possible and always putting your children’s best interests first.
If you have questions about a holiday custody schedule, contact an experienced family law attorney who can help interpret an existing custody order or negotiate or litigate a new or modified one.